I hate to love watching What Not To Wear on TLC. I was stuck with basic cable for a couple of weeks last spring and now I can’t stop watching this horrible, enthralling trainwreck of a show.
If you haven’t seen it, the basic premise is that the friends and family of a badly dressed woman can nominate her to have her wardrobe, fashion sense, core beliefs, and self-worth undermined by the show’s two hosts, Stacy and Clinton, who will then replace her very concept of self with their expensively constructed idea of who she should be.
In other words, they throw out all her old clothes, give her a $5,000 credit limit, and hector her into buying a bunch of unimaginative crap that they think makes her look better.
According to the show’s web site, Stacy graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Vassar College with a double degree in 20th-century philosophy and German literature, and Clinton has a masters in journalism from Northwestern. These are not uneducated people, but my GOD they are condescending.
That hard part for me to take is that sometimes they are absolutely right.
Some of these women do look like hell. They have tattooed on their eyeliner, they proudly wear stuff they found on the street. But you know what? Stacy and Clinton could be nicer about it. At the beginning of one recent show the victim, a bohemian twentysomething schoolteacher, was wearing a choker she made from an old bra strap. Now, me? I’d applaud her for repurposing an unrecyclable garment into a clever accessory before asking her if she might want to think twice before wearing it any place beside Dave & Buster’s, but our hosts just looked at her in abject horror and then mocked her mercilessly. They also mocked her retro t-shirts and flip flops. Instead of celebrating her personal style and giving her tips on how to make it more grown-up, they dramatically threw it all into a shiny galvanized trash can, pushed her around a few Manhattan boutiques and, after the predictable Stockholm Syndrome transition wherein the victim ceases to trust her own taste and begins to love theirs instead, formerly unique Boho Girl came out looking like a clone of our friends Stacy and Clinton.
The point of this whole post is to point you to one of the greatest t-shirt sites in the whole wide Internet. Reckon prints film and TV t-shirts, music t-shirts, literary and art t-shirts, comedy t-shirts – even t-shirts with German philosophers on them — in sizes ranging from infant onesies to burly XXXLs. Stacy and Clinton would cringe if they saw me, a 43-year-old woman, walking around in a Gilda Radner t-shirt, but you know what? Sometimes a weird retro t-shirt is THE PERFECT THING TO WEAR.

Thank you for that. One of the things I don’t like about the show is that they try to get women to look their age– when often the women look quite a bit younger than their age. Why would I want to look my age if I could look younger???
I wear shorts and T-shirts all the time. I am not going to dress up to go to my local coffeeshop and sit there with my computer. Or wear high heels with my jeans to my local bar. I watch the show too– but I don’t think they are always right.
jcreer | July 23rd, 2007 at 3:53 pm
Thanks for the great t-shirt site tip - since I’ve quit my suit-dominated finance job, I’m all about interesting T-shirts with jeans or cargo pants.
Nataly | July 23rd, 2007 at 4:02 pm
Did you ever watch the first season (maybe two) of the show? Stacy used to have a different co-host and they were MUCH meaner back then. I actually find their current mockery absolutely gentle in comparison.
That said, it really is like a glorious trainwreck. I can’t stop watching, even as I know how they’d mock my Threadless tee or even (gasp!) my Fussy tee.
Mir | July 23rd, 2007 at 9:47 pm
I admit, I prefer “How Do I Look?” on Bravo. or is it Style channel? can’t remember. It’s hosted by former General Hospital star Finola Hughes. Similar premise, they remake someone who has been nominated by their family/friends/coworkers for their awful fashion sense. Not sure it has much redeeming value, and when Finola tries to be “fashion therapist” sometimes it gets annoying. But, interestingly, I think I like it because no one is being mean. Meanwhile, I’m counting down the days until the next Project Runway season!!!! Now, that’s my fashion show of choice!
Diane | July 26th, 2007 at 3:27 pm
If they had the fab cut of the fussy t-shirt then perhaps I would buy. I love that shirt even if its slogan is a kind of mockery of my current situation.
ozma | July 26th, 2007 at 8:59 pm
I second Mir’s comment. I could hardly stomach the first season because they were so mean. The first male host was especially nasty and it didn’t help that I never thought he looked especially good. In one episode they couldn’t find a pair of jeans that fit the male contestant, so the host pulled off his own jeans and gave them to the guy, which really bugged me.
sumo | July 26th, 2007 at 9:24 pm
Ooo! They have a Bill Hicks For President T-shirt! And thus, my unwavering devotion. And also my cold, hard cash.
Badger | July 27th, 2007 at 1:21 am
My daughter and husband (!) like that show! Thank goodness I live nowhere near New York; they’d have me on it. Ew.
Daisy | July 29th, 2007 at 12:06 am
They are awfully mean. I am glad that I’m not the only one who feels like they could really do the same job as caring humans instead of evil thugs. I do think that they tie the ‘10 years younger’ show for sheer humiliation of the alleged candidates for change.
liv | July 29th, 2007 at 12:26 am
I still think Stacy & Clinton pale in comparison to the BBC original hosts - Trinny & Susanna.
Nice to see another outlet for your fine writing Mrs. K.
Lori | July 31st, 2007 at 12:34 am
i watch this show all the time. i think they give good tips about what clothing fits different body types. but i do agree that they are overly mean and out to make all the world look exactly like them.
there’s nothing wrong with a cute little goth, punk or bohemian chick. the world needs variety and creative people make it interesting.
Teresa | July 31st, 2007 at 8:14 pm
I too can’t stop watching What Not to Wear…you’re right, what a trainwreck. The part I hate the most, even more than Stacy and Clinton making everyone into clones of themselves, is the inevitable teary “I’m so much more confident now! My life has changed! Stacy and Clinton were right!” speech. Ew.
amy | August 2nd, 2007 at 2:53 am
I hate hate hate WNTW, and yet, am mezmerized ! I love the british version, though!
My big complaint is that really I am not that into what is “in” right now, and frankly I also refuse to wear anything that I don’t want to be thrown up on.
CouryG | August 8th, 2007 at 2:47 pm