Featured Blogs
Milk and Cookies
Watching lately: what DVDs have we been renting
The Working Closet
Making a list, and checking it twice, or how to get ready to actually SHOP
The 36-Hour Day
Chaos May Make for a Good Blog Post
Cornered Office
Handling reader emails
The Work It, Mom! Blog
Casual Friday --- May 16th, 2008
Moms On Issues
Stage Moms: Working mothers in the extreme
Ordering Disorder
Side Dish Recipe: Mango Rice Pilaf
Explore Work It, Mom!
Moms On Issues
Posted by Veronica on April 21st, 2008

pay checkFriday was Fair Pay Day, marking the day when women have finally earned enough money to equal how much money a man earned all of 2007. Yes, according to those who study the wage gap, the 23 cents women, on average, aren’t making compared to an average man, it takes us until April 18th to make up.

Of course the wage gap isn’t as cut and dry as just a mere 24 cents. Considering that most of the world is set up by a white male standard (don’t even pretend it isn’t, folks), let’s look at the wage gap for different women:

  • White Man - $1.00
    • African-American woman - 63 cents
    • Latina woman - 52 cents
    • Women physicians - 72 cents
    • Women in sales - 64 cents
    • Women in construction - 86 cents
    • Women in computer and mathematical occupations - 85 cents
    • Women 25 years of age+ with some high school education median annual earnings were $15,162, compared to $24,092 for men
    • Graduation from high school boosted women’s median earnings to $21,609, yet the same high school degree yielded $33,074 for men
    • Women with a two-year associate’s degree gives men a much bigger bang for their buck ($42,462 in median annual earnings) than it does for women ($29,091)
    • Women earning a bachelor’s degree yielded a median annual of income of $38,221 - $55,425 for men
    • Data from the NWLC Pay Equity Fact Sheet [PDF link]

    A bit somber eh? And while many will poo-poo these data points with the old “women opt for low-paying jobs” or “if women didn’t take time for children…” bullshit excuses, I don’t buy them and neither should you. In AAUW’s 2007 report Behind the Pay Gap, they were able to calculate the wage gap as early as the first year on the job between men and women who earned the same college degree and major. The wage gap only grows from there. Of course the choices we make do make a difference, but there is still a good amount of the gap that is not explained by our reproduction or what school we attended.

    But as we are curious about our own pay checks, I believe we should be equally curious about the people, 97% of whom are women, who are caring for our children while we schlep to the office.

    In 2006, child care workers earned an average of just $9.05 an hour, or $18,820 annually. In comparison, baggage porters earned an average of $21,580 annually and pet sitters earned an average of $20,230 annually. Child care workers are also often denied other important and necessary benefits, such as health care and sick leave. Because of the low wages and limited benefits associated with child care work, many women in the industry are forced to take on second jobs.

    I know that on our end here in Chicago, we are paying a second mortgage each month for our daughter’s day care. I can’t imagine paying more than that, but at the same time I wonder how the wonderful women who do care and love my daughter are making ends meet. While I muse about how little my daughter’s caregivers are making, I also fume over how much more jobs of lessen value pay. Pet sitters earning more than a child care worker? WTF? I guess because a dog sitter can watch 10 dogs at a time and a child care worker can only watch 4 infants at a time or about 10 pre-schoolers at a time. But still, people…

    Is the answer more government intervention? Or heck, some government intervention? Perhaps. Could it be looking at the profit margin of large child care companies? I do lean pretty far on the socialist side of things, so my gut says yes. We need to have the government help subsidize child care. If I can afford $500 a week, but my caregiver really needs us to pay $750 to earn a living wage, then the government should ante up. Or peek at the balance sheet of the company to see if the CEO is making a zillion dollars while the workers are making barely $20,000 a year. Yes, I do believe that the gap between the very top and the very bottom should be as small as possible.

    And this is why I believe that many have started to call Friday Fair Pay day and not just equal pay day. By calling it Fair Pay day, we can look at women-dominated jobs and ask, “Is that really fair?” If we just looked at equal pay, we’d look at caregivers and say, “Hey, they all make the same lousy wage. It’s equal!”

    Readers — Have you ever wondered if you were getting a fair wage? If the schlemiel next to you was earning $5,000 more year or not? Want to do something about it?

    “Our struggle today is not to have a female Einstein get appointed as an assistant professor. It is for a woman schlemiel to get as quickly promoted as a male schlemiel.” - Bella Abzug

    Like this blog?

    This entry was posted on Monday, April 21st, 2008 at 7:00 am and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

    Tags: , , , , ,

    6 Responses to “Fair Pay Day - For Working moms? Caregivers? Both?”

    • Mandy says:

      The underpaid caregiver issues has made me bitter for years. If I could afford to pay my babysitter more, I would, no doubt about it. As it is she’s making more than her friends (they are all college students) because it is my belief that she is doing the most important job there is. And she deserves it.

      As for a fair wage for myself, yes, I can luckily say I do get a fair wage for my (almost always). I figure I have enough experience behind me and have honed my talent enough that I deserve what I make and won’t settle for less. Unless, of course, it’s for a non profit then that’s all out the window

      I’m going to look into that act a little more. Thanks for the link to the petition!

    • selfmademom says:

      Unfortunately, this issue isn’t just for caregivers or women. I just read in the NY Times about steel workers, who used to earn $20/ hr (which would help get them into the middle class) are barely making ends meet with those wages. I think it’s also about raising our national minimum wage average. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I think it’s way below the national average!

    • Veronica says:

      The federal minimum wage is $5.85 and will go up to $7.25 by July 2009.

      http://www.laborlawcenter.com/federal-minimum-wage.asp

      Of course, I was making $7.25 in college selling shoes. Which is really maddening when you try to figure out how anyone is living off of minimum wage.

    • Daisy says:

      I left the child care field for two reasons: lack of pay and lack of respect. Now I’m a public school teacher, and I earn, well, a little more of both. At least it’s enough to pay the mortgage! My child care wages barely covered the rent.

    • MaryP says:

      I’m a childcare provider who makes a decent wage, but only because of where I live and the fact that I’m independent, and work from my own home. If I worked through an agency, I’d earn less than half what I currently make. If I worked in a daycare center, I’d make about half.

      But I’m lucky. Childcare providers who live a mere 5 km from me make half to 2/3 what I make. My university degrees and teaching experience help a lot to convince parents I’m worth what I charge, I’m sure, but a lot of it is just plain old geography.

    • Are SAHMs the next "cheap labor?" - Moms On Issues - Work It, Mom! says:

      […] With these low standards we are setting for ourselves, how will we ever achieve “fair pay?” […]

    Leave a Comment