Hillary, Barack and Gender Double Standards
Categories: PunditMom Ponders, We're More Political Than You Think
Gloria Steinem raised a really interesting question this week in the New York Times about gender (one I wish I would have thought of first!):
If Barack Obama was a woman with the same experience and history, would we even be talking about whether” she” was a qualified candidate?
Steinem thinks the answer is, unfortunately, clear.
Steinem asks:
“The woman in question became a lawyer after some years as a community organizer, married a corporate lawyer and is the mother of two little girls, ages 9 and 6. Herself the daughter of a white American mother and a black African father — in this race-conscious country, she is considered black — she served as a state legislator for eight years, and became an inspirational voice for national unity.
“Be honest: Do you think this is the biography of someone who could be elected to the United States Senate? After less than one term there, do you believe she could be a viable candidate to head the most powerful nation on earth?”
Her point is a good one. Odds are, if you break it down that way, many of us would say “no.”
The only fact that was changed was gender, and, suddenly, one has to wonder whether that person should have a little more seasoning before embarking on a White House crusade. Applying that test to others, it really gave me pause.
But it also made me wonder, would candidate Hillary Clinton carry the gravitas we seem to think a presidential candidate should have if she wasn’t related to Bill Clinton? There are numerous other women Senators, who have much more political experience than Hillary, but they’re not in the race for the White House.
While we sometimes think that as women we’ve come a long way baby, in some respects we are still stuck in the gender stone ages, from (I sheepishly admit) relying on our husbands to take out the trash while we’re throwing in a load of laundry, to believing, at least on a subliminal level, that if two candidates are equal in every other way, we would believe that the one with the Y chromosome is up to the task, but the XX-er, not so much.
As a result of Steinem’s article, I’m looking at all the candidates in a brand new light. What about you?

You know I am. I hope others are as well. Not that I’m going to start advocating for HRC, but just for everyone to look at the Dem race a bit closer.
Veronica | January 10th, 2008 at 4:11 am
I don’t think it’s a gender double standard — most men with Obama’s resume would be dismissed out of hand as well. What makes him different is that he is a powerful and inspiring speaker. I think a black woman with Obama’s talents would be more hindered by there not being a tradition of powerful female orators than by the resume.
Hillary is a unique woman as well. I can’t imagine crashing through a bigger glass ceiling than breaking out of the “wife of” role and into a Senate seat. Usually that only happens when the husband dies and people are sentimental and don’t like the other candidate.
It will be an interesting race. I haven’t decided who I favor.
SoftwareMom | January 10th, 2008 at 11:29 am
This whole race has me all torn. While I admire Obama, I really resent the way Hillary is attacked. Okay, yes, she plays the system to the hilt and perhaps that’s not a good thing. (Er, remember the heinous photo op with the troops in Baghdad?) On the other hand, I don’t think she deserves what she has to endure.
I also read Gloria Steinem’s NYTimes piece and found it really inspiring and disturbing.
Diane | January 11th, 2008 at 2:40 am
i love this take (though havent read the article - yet) and totally agree that gender should in no way be a deciding factor. to me, speaches are great! and inspiring! but what does that have to do with being the president? so we will all watch the presidential address and beem with pride and purpose for an hour or two? or do we want someone who knows the system and how to get things done with in it? anyone who has managed people knows you need a little bit of both - inspiration AND action. i think HRC (love that!) has a lead in that respect, she is well spoken too - maybe Obama can be her speach writer? ha!
Kate | January 11th, 2008 at 4:44 pm
I think there are plenty of people who are questioning Obama’s experience level. He’s inspiring, yes, but I’ve not heard much in the way of foreign policy from him.
I’m voting for whomever can survive the Republican mean machine. This is the strangest election I can remember because there’s no one “annointed” by the GOP yet, so we don’t yet know what the playing field is going to look like.
Lisse | January 12th, 2008 at 3:34 am
[...] there are ways to get all political this year without having to deal with the presidential candidates! Like this blog? Submit to: Digg Facebook del.icio.us sk-rt This entry was posted on Thursday, [...]
What's Wrong with a Plastic Sippy Cup? - PunditMom's Spin Cycle - Work It, Mom! | February 14th, 2008 at 3:40 am
So who, then, is the real candidate for change… ?
Jim W. | February 24th, 2008 at 4:35 am